Friday, March 30, 2007
To Protect the Child
When I was a kid, there were consolation prizes in school contests. Until we understood the appallingly patronising semantics, we saw it as the legitimate last rung in the hierarchy of awards. Then there were middle-school debates that were sanctimoniously labelled "academic" (euphemism for "rigged at the time of deciding the topic") lest our sensitive minds be exposed to acrimony and disagreement.
Not too many years ago, kids versions of television contest (mostly singing talent shows) never announced winners—every participant took home the same crummy gift-hamper.
Now apparently, this Super Singer Junior reality show on Vijay TV has pictures of kids being rejected (they have candy I suppose), also of kids behaving like little spoilt divas, and also of kids singing really well and winning.
Then I came across this (via). Now I may not entirely agree with a dogmatic view about "good competition", but I do see in my line of work that a system of incentives (and disincentives) really produces results, if the system is deemed to be even nominally "just" by its members.
Kids, I have seen, have a terrific sense of morality, fairness and "right".
Comments to To Protect the Child
Chenthil has given you ooru sooper title ? Kurosowa of Kodambakkam ;-)
posted by K.Shyam12:16 am, April 02, 2007
ama ama, psbb le elarukum consolation prize dhan..
posted by I7:08 pm, April 02, 2007
Nice post, its a really cool blog that you have here, keep up the good work, will be back.
Biby Cletus - Blog
posted by Biby Cletus8:39 pm, April 02, 2007
You might be aware of Alfie Kohn's famous paper Studies Find Reward Often No Motivator. A very famous open source project redistributes this paper along with the software.
Psychologists have been finding that rewards can lower performance levels, especially when the performance involves creativity.
posted by BNB10:18 pm, April 02, 2007
posted by Sammpath8:01 pm, May 01, 2007
References to To Protect the Child
This work is licensed under aCreative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 2.5 License.